Thursday, 11 July 2019

Alexander Nelson (1737-1803), pioneer of Old Barns

Updated 16 July 2019

I first mentioned my 4x great grandfather, Alexander Nelson (abt 1837-1803) in this early blog post. Alexander settled in Old Barns, which was in Truro Township, Nova Scotia, having received a Crown land grant.

Among the files I've received recently from a new-found cousin is this extract of an article written by Rev John W. Nelson in about 1900 (I'm probably related to him, but that is research that remains to be done), that was part of a larger manuscript now in the Nova Scotia Archives (and I absolutely want to know more that manuscript). It tells more about Alexander and his wife, my 4x great grandmother, Margaret Robinson (1735-1823). I am especially pleased with what I take as official, albeit still anecdotal, confirmation of Alexander's service under General Wolfe at the Plains of Abraham in 1759, which comes from his grandson, who "was positive" about that fact. See the second paragraph here:

courtesy of Karen Nelson
This extract tells us for the first time that Alexander had at least two brothers who also came from Scotland to New England. This will open up new research for Alexander's parentage in Scotland, not to mention his brothers who joined him in America.

The extract also gives us insight into Alexander as a man.

The Miller book mentioned in the extract refers to the 1873 book by Thomas Miller, First Settlers of Colchester County (N.S.) Below the title is added: down to the present time. Compiled from the most authentic sources. Chapter 12 of the book is about the Nelson family.

In the early 2000s, I provided my own family's descent from Alexander and Margaret to a Colchester historian, Jane Wile, who self-published Descendants of Alexander Nelson & Margaret Robinson of Truro Township, Nova Scotia in 2006. Jane begins her compilation with this:



I have seen unsupported references online suggesting that Alexander Nelson was at the second siege of Louisbourg on Cape Breton in 1758. The Fortress of Louisbourg confirmed to me recently that their historian has no record of an Alexander Nelson at that event.

Alexander received his Old Barns land grant in 1761. He returned to Massachusetts over that winter, and in the spring, married Margaret. Did he know her before he went to Nova Scotia? Or did they meet when he returned from there?


from Old Barns, Clifton and Princeport area by Eda M. Nelson, 1908

I've found supporting sources for Alexander and Margaret's Massachusetts marriage on 15 Apr 1762, which was recorded in town registers of Milton, where Alexander lived, and Dunstable, where Margaret lived. I think that soon after they married, Alexander and Margaret made their way to their Crown land grant in Truro Township, Nova Scotia.

Massachusetts, Town Vital Collections, 1620-1988

All of their 13 children were born in Nova Scotia:
  • Elizabeth 1763-
  • William Montague 1765-1842
  • Agnes 1767-1805
  • Archibald 1768-1861
  • Charles 1771-1847
  • John 1772-1857
  • James 1773-1858
  • Robinson 1774-1850
  • Jane 1775
  • Margaret 1779-1826
  • Alexander 1781-1839
  • Elias 1783-1871 (my 3x great grandfather)
  • Alice 1785-
  • Rebecca 1787-1818
Initially, I wrote that they had at least 12 children. Since starting my blog, I've found a confirmed 13th child. As you can imagine, Alexander and Margaret had many, many, many grandchildren.



The never ending story continues....






© Margaret Dougherty 2016-2019 All rights reserved

Monday, 8 July 2019

'The Deserted Village' and the St. Lawrence Seaway

Like any avid genealogist, I often turn to newspaper archives seeking birth, marriage and death announcements, along with anything really, that is relevant to my family. Or not. Especially the to'ing and fro'ing reported in the 'social notes' -- these columns were definitely a precursor to today's social media, gossip websites, blogs and print magazines. Time can pass so quickly when you get lost in the whole 'just one more click' world of trolling old newspapers.

Recently, in one of those research kicks, I came across a lengthy letter to the editor written by my father's older brother.

Montreal Gazette, 3 Mar 1956

This is a truly excellent and insightful letter. Construction of the St Lawrence Seaway and its future impact was evidently causing great consternation for Montrealers and others living along what would become its path, between Montreal and Lake Ontario.

My uncle died in 1962, six years after writing this letter, leaving a widow and five children, ranging in age from 11 to 18. I was so pleased to share this gem with my cousins, who never got to know and interact with their father as adults. Marcus' reference in his letter to the Oliver Goldsmith poem, The Deserted Village, first published in 1770, especially impressed one of his sons. Reading this epic poem, I think that Marcus' reference to it is spot on. Have a read.

The St Lawrence Seaway opened in 1959. While I don't believe Marcus' letter had any effect on its engineering and construction, certainly his linking of its effect to Goldsmith's poem was inspired, and I suspect sent many Montreal Gazette editorial page readers hunting for their books of poetry (this was decades before Google searches, after all).

The never ending story continues....




© Margaret Dougherty 2016-2019 All rights reserved

Saturday, 6 July 2019

How Old Barns got its name


Old Barns, where my paternal 4th great grandfather, Alexander Nelson (abt 1737-1803), settled in Colchester, Nova Scotia, was originally farmland of Acadians expelled from Nova Scotia and New Brunswick beginning in 1755.

The area is described vividly in this extract from an unknown source:

Nelson family papers from Nova Scotia Archives
Nelson family papers from Nova Scotia Archives
Those barns were all that remained of Acadian families' farm fields and structures, which were burned by the British. Among my great aunt Letitia Nelson's possessions found after her death in 1941 was a copy of a painting of Evangeline, the fictional heroine of William Wadsworth Longfellow's poem, Evangeline, A Tale of Acadie, written in 1847. The painting is still in Nelson family hands today.




The never ending story continues....




© Margaret Dougherty 2016-2019 All rights reserved

Friday, 28 June 2019

Charlotte Butler Nelson memorial window dedicated at First Baptist Church 2


As I said in my post here about the church stained glass window dedicated to my great
grandmother, in all the references I found about this, she is referred to as Mrs Elias Nelson.


When I contacted the First Baptist Church in Truro hoping to have a photo of
the window, I referred to my great grandmother as Charlotte Butler Nelson. They had trouble finding anything until I sent them an excerpt from the dedication service program and a newspaper story about the event.

Success. I soon received two photos. You can see why they had trouble finding the window.

It's a beautiful window that remains installed in First Baptist Church to this day, almost 53 years after it was dedicated.

I'm glad that women are now known by their own names, and not those of their husbands, and understand that it was different era, but it really wasn't that long ago.

The never ending story continues....













© Margaret Dougherty 2016-2018 All rights reserved

Wednesday, 26 June 2019

Are you sure? Is it this Donald Smith or that Donald Smith?

Experienced genealogists know well the peril of integrating people found in another person's unsourced family tree into their own, and then using that unsourced tree as their source. This is a big red flag, and often creates an endless loop of wrong information. It happens even more now, with the explosion in the popularity of genealogy as a hobby. I go out of our way to always avoid this black hole.

Now, imagine how much further complication is introduced when you're working with a name like Donald Smith. Well, I don't have to imagine, because my 3rd great grandfather is Donald Smith (abt 1774-bef 1841).

not my 4th great grandparents
Some Ancestry trees are linking my Donald to an unrelated couple as being his parents. Because of this, with the introduction of the otherwise fabulous Ancestry ThruLines earlier this year, I'm now seeing a Donald Smith, farmer, Cnoc of Croughly in Banffshire and a Janet Stuart as being my potential 4th great grandparents. But they're just not. And my Donald is not their son. There are no source documents attached to the trees in which these people are found, except for "Ancestry trees".

Now, I'm the first to admit that I don't know who my Donald Smith's parents are, but they're definitely not Donald Smith, farmer at Cnoc of Croughly and Janet Stuart. Their son is another Donald Smith, specifically, one Donald Smith, who was born and baptized on 14 Sep 1775 at Kirkmichael, Banffshire. There's a baptismal record saying so. This Donald Smith married another Smith (I know!), Margaret Smith, who was born and baptized in 1779 also in Kirkmichael, Banffshire. As a matter of interest, this Margaret Smith's mother was also a Smith. This Donald and Margaret had a family of at least seven children:



Cnoc -- or Knock -- of Croughly was a place in Banffshire in Scotland, I learned from Scotland's Places. In the 18th century, this and Ballcorach in Kirkmichael, Banffshire, where the above family were born, would have been a fair distance from Tulloch, in Strathspey, Inverness-shire.

I wrote about the children of my 3rd great grandparents, Donald Smith (who was a stonemason) and Margaret Davidson here but here's a chart too.



I know these are small images, but I use these to illustrate the overlapping similar names in both families. Aside from the fact that both families are led by couples named Donald and Margaret, there are Anns, Donalds and Peters in both families.

Naturally, the similar names would lead some to think that they've got the right family when they come across Donald Smith and Margaret Smith of Ballcorach in Kirkmichael, Banffshire. But this is not the right family. Here's what Scotland's Places says about Ballcorach's location.

Scotland's Places - about Ballcorach, Banffshire

And here's the description of Tulloch:

Scotland's Places - about Tulloch, Inverness-shire 

I have a paper trail of my Smiths, including baptismal, marriage and death records and censuses. I've also found a similar paper trail for the children of Donald Smith and Margaret Smith. These are two, separate and distinct families living in adjacent counties but not close, as the crow flies, as they say.

The kicker that the Balcorach Smiths are not the parents of my 3rd great grandfather, Donald Smith of Tulloch was finding the Will of Donald Smith of Ballcorach. His bequests to his children by name did it for me, in terms of confirmation.

With special thanks again to Scottish genealogist Jenny Blain for her much appreciated research assistance and on the ground knowledge too.

The never ending story continues....




© Margaret Dougherty 2016-2019 All rights reserved

Sunday, 23 June 2019

Found! Isabella Smith's baptismal record

I'm lucky to live near the excellent Toronto Reference Library and that it is a partner library of FamilySearch, the genealogical records mecca based in Utah.

A few weeks ago, I took myself to the Toronto Reference Library to look at the image attached to the FamilySearch baptism transcription of my maternal 2nd great grandmother, Isabella Smith (1817-1915).

Jackpot! I found the Old Parish Record that confirmed details about both Isabella and my 3rd great grandparents, Donald Smith and Margaret Davidson.


I needed help making out the specific place name before the word Tulloch seen above. I learned that this is Tomghobhain, Gaelic for Smith Hill, a place that is mentioned in this Electric Scotland page, In the Shadow of Cairngorm, which also mentions Abernethy, and place mentioned in many of my Ross and Matheson records.

I knew from Margaret Davidson's obituary, which you can see here, that Donald Smith was from Tulloch. In another great online resource, Scotland's Places, Tulloch is described as:

 "a well-known district on the west side of the River Nethy in the County of Inverness".
Nethy is a place where many of my ancestors lived.

Slowly the pieces of the puzzle of my Smith ancestors is starting to unravel.

With special thanks to Scottish genealogist Jenny Blain for her much appreciated research assistance.

The never ending story continues....




© Margaret Dougherty 2016-2019 All rights reserved

Charlotte Butler Nelson memorial window dedicated at First Baptist Church 1

photo courtesy of Karen Nelson

My Nova Scotia great grandmother, Charlotte Butler Nelson, was a devout Baptist. She joined the First Baptist Church in Truro in 1886, and remained an active member of the congregation for the rest of her days -- that would be 60 years in all.

In 1966, 20 years after her death, Charlotte's son Robert donated a stained glass window depicting the Resurrection to the First Baptist Church in her memory. As was the practice of the time, in all references to this event, she is referred to as Mrs Elias Nelson. Times changed.
Truro Daily News

The window was dedicated at the church is a special service on 10 Jul 1966, and reported on in the Truro Daily News.

Sadly, I don't think the window is installed any longer. I've contacted the church on Facebook, hoping to have a photo of the window. I provided them the story you see here, together with the dedication service program.

They're still looking. What happened to the window, I wonder?

The never ending story continues....







© Margaret Dougherty 2016-2019 All rights reserved

About the Family of Robert Young and Isabella Knox

I wrote about my great grandfather, Robert Alexander Young , here . Now it's time to write about the family he and my great grandmother...